The short answer
Choose listed companies that do the same thing at a similar scale, work out what each trades at as a multiple of revenue, EBITDA or profit, and take the median. Multiply the company’s own figure by that median. An enterprise value multiple gives the value of the whole business, so take off net debt to reach the value of the shares; a P/E multiple gives the value of the shares directly.
Step 1: choose the peers
The whole method rests on this step. A peer should earn its money the same way: the same products or services, sold to the same kind of customer. Industry codes are a starting point and often a poor one, because a single code can hold businesses with very different economics. Size, geography and profitability matter too: a loss-making company has no meaningful P/E, and a business ten times larger may trade at a premium the smaller one would never earn.
Write down every company you considered and left out, with the reason. A peer set is a judgement, and the first question anybody reviewing it asks is why a particular name is missing.
Step 2: work out the multiples
Enterprise value (EV) = market capitalisation + debt − cash
- EV/Revenue: useful for young or loss-making businesses, but blind to how profitable each one is.
- EV/EBITDA: the most common, because it compares operating earnings before the effects of debt, tax and depreciation policy.
- P/E: share price over earnings per share, or market capitalisation over profit after tax. It reflects each company’s debt and tax, so it compares equity with equity.
Use figures for the same period for every company, and leave a cell blank when a figure is not known rather than filling it with zero.
Step 3: take the median, and look at the outliers
Use the median rather than the average, so that one company trading at an unusual multiple does not drag the answer. But look at the outlier before setting it aside: a peer at a far higher multiple may be one that has just been bought, at a price a real buyer paid.
Step 4: apply it, and get to the value of the shares
An unlisted company makes ₹8 crore of EBITDA and ₹4.5 crore of profit after tax, and has ₹15 crore of net debt. Five listed peers trade at 9.5, 11.0, 12.5, 14.0 and 18.0 times EBITDA, and at 18, 20, 22, 25 and 30 times earnings.
| Item | EV/EBITDA route | P/E route |
|---|---|---|
| Median multiple | 12.5x | 22x |
| Applied to | EBITDA ₹8 crore | Profit after tax ₹4.5 crore |
| Gives | Enterprise value ₹100 crore | Equity value ₹99 crore |
| Less net debt | ₹15 crore | Already reflected |
| Value of the shares | ₹85 crore | ₹99 crore |
The two routes rarely agree exactly. Differences in debt, tax and depreciation between the company and its peers pull them apart, which is why a valuation usually presents a range from the methods used rather than a single figure.
The mistake that matters most
Never subtract debt from a value found with P/E, and never forget to subtract it from a value found with an EV multiple. An EV multiple values the whole business, lenders included; P/E values only the shares. Mixing them up overstates or understates a company with debt by the whole of that debt.
Terms in this guide
Sources
- ICAI Valuation Standards 2018, including Valuation Standard 103: Valuation Approaches and Methods The Institute of Chartered Accountants of India